August 14, 2022

Distinctive: Just one UNION Phone calls FOR INQUIRY INTO Main Executive OF PARLIAMENTARY Products and services

“This is an unambiguous and dark warning to victims of bullying in parliament: maintain tranquil and don’t occur ahead.” 

One particular UNION has penned to the Speaker of the Dwelling currently requesting he acquire action from the chief government of Parliamentary Services above his conduct relating to bullying by Mr Nick Smith MP. 

The union alleges Mr Rafael Gonzalez-Montero and some others cynically utilized the target and the complainant as pawns in a marketing campaign to get rid of Smith. After Smith was compelled to resign, the target and the witness ended up deserted. 


The Summary  

Main govt Gonzalez-Montero forced a youthful victim, versus his needs, to take part in a yr-very long investigation from Smith. 

The main govt promised the target he would personally defend his nicely-currently being, his work and his profession. A similar guarantee was made to the principal witness of the bullying. 

Instead, during the investigation neither of the junior staffers had their employment contracts renewed. They lost their work opportunities, and their parliamentary professions are over. The victim nevertheless owes revenue for the attorney he was appointed by the main government. 

TDB Suggests

Gonzalez-Montero’s law firm has threatened the victim and myself that if 1 Union goes community with their story, Parliamentary Companies may well sue the sufferer and myself personally for damages. Smith was a bully and was held accountable. But, Gonzalez-Montero’s steps, are these of an abuser. He really should be held accountable as well. 

The Francis Report two decades back mentioned parliament was toxic and abuse was rampant. It produced 83 suggestions. Very little has altered.

We ask for the Speaker concur to the following:

  • Keep an inquiry into Gonzalez-Montero’s dealing with of this subject.  
  • Direct the CEO to response the union thoughts on this situation.
  • Launch the closing investigation report.
  • Present an update on 2018 Francis report.


The Background  

In August 2020 Parliamentary Providers chief government Rafael Gonzalez-Montero introduced a official investigation into the bullying by Nick Smith versus a junior workers member in July. Soon after Smith was suggested of the grievance, he countered with a complaint from the alleged victim. 

The main government summoned the younger staffer to his business and encouraged he was currently being investigated far too, and he was required to co-operate with the inquiry. The young staffer reported he didn’t want to be involved due to the fact he felt it would hurt his job. He was suitable, it wrecked it. The main executive explained the staffer didn’t have a alternative. 


The Promise  

Gonzalez-Montero, on the other hand, assured the victim that he had almost nothing to concern. He made a heartfelt personalized assure that as chief executive he would secure the staffer’s wellbeing, his work, and his career in parliament. A equivalent reassurance was offered to the primary witness who was the real complainant. 

The chief govt said this was a probability for parliament to show it would keep strong folks accountable. It would seem Gonzalez-Montero was motivated by the Francis Report two several years earlier that experienced lambasted the poisonous parliament lifestyle and recognized a lot of instances of bullying and abuse. The report manufactured 83 suggestions and claimed parliament had to take action.


Under the Bus 

Gonzalez-Montero furnished the sufferer a lawyer. The initially invoices have been paid. Then they stopped. After that the target experienced to borrow from his household to pay out the authorized expenses.   

When the preliminary inquiry report was finally created, it was shared with the members. A brutal media smear marketing campaign was right away launched towards the sufferer and the witness, causing massive pressure to the two younger people. It was obvious specific media experienced been briefed against the personnel. As the assaults intensified the sufferer requested a conference with Gonzalez-Montero. The main govt instructed the sufferer to fulfill at a Wellington café instead than his place of work. 

At this assembly the staffer begged the chief executive to put out the details in a media assertion to counter the lies. Gonzalez-Montero position blank refused, stating he experienced a broader responsibility to preserve interactions with politicians. It is crystal clear his obligations, in his mind, did not incorporate telling the fact, preserving his guarantees, or defending his employees. 

When the victim asked what his authorized grievance solutions had been, he was recommended that path would not be very good for his future vocation.


The Resignation

When the inquiry report was finalised, its findings had been the identical as what was said in the draft report. It verified that Smith was guilty of bullying and harassment. It also found the sufferer innocent. The target and his attorney had been permitted to read through the total report but have no copy.

When then National Party chief Judith Collins told Smith the report was about be leaked, he straight away resigned from parliament. Gonzalez-Montero refuses to affirm who has copies. Did Judith Collins? The chief govt refuses to launch the last report. 


The Betrayal 

The union believes the victim was applied as a political pawn in an interior social gathering ability participate in. The chief government, with his wilful silence, betrayed his workforce. 

Despite Gonzalez-Montero’s early assurances, the work contracts for the sufferer and the witness have been not renewed. Neither are now employed in parliament. When the political hatchet work was accomplished, the main government misplaced interest. 

This is an unambiguous and dark warning to victims of bullying in parliament: keep peaceful and do not arrive forward. 


The Sordid Aftermath

Since the victim was compelled by Gonzalez-Montero to cooperate with the year-very long investigation he is now in financial debt. Anyone else experienced their legal fees picked up by the taxpayer. 

Gonzalez-Montero at present is supplying no payment to the sufferer. Evidently, they do not want to set a precedent. He and his attorney say if they are expected to go to a mediation, their placement will not change. 

The senior legislation spouse symbolizing Gonzalez-Montero says he is very calm. Specified they are compensated near to $1000 an hour, which is no surprise. The taxpayer funded trough is very deep for all those who protect the effective towards the susceptible. 

Gonzalez-Montero has been at pains to say to the union how terrible he feels for the sufferer.  

When I reminded him of his before promise to safeguard the victim and his occupation, the main government in the beginning claimed he could not bear in mind the meeting. When I  explained he had despatched an e-mail to the staffer to make an appointment with his secretary, and National’s main of team experienced confirmed she was existing, he available to put in a fantastic word for any future suitable career vacancies the victim may well apply. No guarantees of training course. This is further than muddle-headed idiocy. Who thinks like this? 

Gonzalez-Montero is paid out hundreds of 1000’s of dollars to guide in excess of two thousand personnel in parliament. He would not previous a working day in the personal sector.


The Primary Minister 

This deep injustice transpired on Jacinda Ardern’s enjoy. The primary minister asks us to be sort to every single other. We agree. There are moments for soothing words and an empathetic smile. But in this matter, agency action is needed.

Character integrity is measured by how we take care of people with little electricity. This is a time for the key minister and the Speaker to instruct Gonzalez-Montero to resolve this mess he created. Or sack him. 




Matt McCarten is Union Director of 1 Union. 

Support us get justice for victims of exploitation and abuse in non-unionised workplaces. Go to, or absolutely free cellphone 0800 368 000.

Report cases of mistreatment and unfairness, donate to our operate and join us.